The governor, Jan Brewer, said that she was forced to take matters into her own hands as Washington wasn't doing their part to prevent illegal immigrants from being in the country and in her state. "We in Arizona have been more than patient waiting for Washington to act," said Brewer, a Republican facing a tough re-election challenge. "But decades of inaction and misguided policy have created a dangerous and unacceptable situation."
When I first heard about this, I immediately thought of racial profiling and how horrible a law like this will be for people, especially people of color in the state of Arizona. In one of my previous posts I mentioned that racism is alive and well in our country, and unfortunately it is things like this that will continue to perpetuate racism and prevent equality.
Benjamin E. Johnson, executive director of the American Immigration Council, opposes the law but says the question of whether it is "unconstitutional on its face is unclear." An easier question, in his mind, is whether the law will lead to constitutional violations, such as unlawful searches and seizures or discrimination based on protected characteristics such as race or ethnicity. "That seems to me the much greater risk," Johnson says. The law requires noncitizens in Arizona to carry their immigration paperwork with them at all times. That clearly would be an example of the state intruding into exclusively federal domains of enforcement and regulation and will inevitably lead to racial profiling.
I know that this issue is not directly related to higher education right at this very minute, however, immigration is definitely a hot topic in the media as well as how we support our undocumented students. This topic is definitely something that we are continuing to talk about on campuses across the country, as the number of undocumented students are increasing. I know that this is something that UNC is continuing to talk about as we continue to understand the population around our campus and who is coming to our campus.
A law like this, just shows that one is not welcome in the state and that they are clearly not wanted. And in the end will result in more and more issues of racism and inequality, something that we are trying to work against I thought.
Instead of removing people from our country and sending them back to their native country why don't we offer support and provide the necessary steps from them to become a U.S. citizen. The United States of America is a free country, well that is what we are taught in school, but are we truly?
ReplyDeleteErin, great job on this blog. It pretty clear that you are pretty passionate about the issue. I immediately thought of "racial profiling" when this all passed and am tuned in to see what will result from this. Good job.
ReplyDeleteIs America really a land of the free and a home for the brave? I don't think so! Drawing on my experiences of growing up in an agriculture community where workers from Mexico were heavily utilized I saw no freedom for these workers and the only braveness I saw was staying in the US not getting here. Are we forcing immigrants to jump from the frying pan into the fire? More often than not, immigrants come to the US to have a better life; if they really knew what they were facing would they chose to come to America?
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading this post and I have had my own "spirited" conversations concerning this exact topic. I cannot believe our country continues to think of ways to make racial profiling legal. Where is the justice in this? I am boycotting Arizonia until they change their law.
ReplyDeleteAlethea
After the news channels covered the story, I kept wondering what the cops will do to me while I'm in AZ. Just based on my ethnicity, will they really pull me over and ask me for my passport and visa? I don't know how the police is going to implement the bill, but I was thinking about the possibility for being pulled over and asked for legal immigration documents. Just because I'm a minority, the chance will so much higher than non-minorities. This sounds annoying to me.
ReplyDelete